Why ISACA Certifications Will Supercede ITIL

Below is a list of the top reasons ISACA’s COBIT Foundation and CGEIT certifications will become more popular than ITIL certifications. I am not suggesting the ITIL certifications will go away or be replaced by ISACA, in part because their frameworks are complementary and not entirely competitive. Nevertheless, ITIL and COBIT going in different directions, particularly ITIL doing everything wrong and COBIT doing things mostly right.

  1. ITIL V3 framework has become complicated and convoluted. Although ITIL V3 is supposed to provide clearer guidance for implementation, in most cases it is simply too complicated for organizations who still desire a piecemeal approach. Most IT practitioners still think in ITIL V2 terms (Incident, Problem, Change, Configuration) and ignore the V3 additions.
  2. COBIT is more rigorous and intellectually consistent. It lends itself easier to auditing. Many organizations wish to adhere to SOX requirements, even if they are not publicly traded. On the other hand, I haven’t yet seen an organization that desires ISO/IEC 20000 certification.
  3. ISACA documentation is more readily available to organizations at affordable prices. ITIL documentation has become expensive, and an apparent moneymaker for OGC and its related organizations.
  4. ITIL certifications (beyond Foundation) require classroom training that are mostly a moneymaking racket for APM Group and the OGC. Few will afford the $10K plus costs to obtain higher levels of certification–fewer will want to. ITIL Foundation will remain far more popular than the higher certifications, even among practitioners with significant experience with ITIL.
  5. The COBIT Foundation certification is similar in structure to the ITIL Foundation, and serves the same basic function. The two are equivalent and complementary, and COBIT Foundation will soon become as popular as ITIL Foundation. I believe this was a brilliant move by ISACA.
  6. The CGEIT requires real-world experience, in addition to a structured exam. In this way CGEIT is similar to CISA and PMI’s PMP certifications, both of which are very popular and respected.